The commentary was initially published in 1967,1 with an english edition in 1979. Born in vienna as an austrian citizen, he moved to cambridge as an adult and later was forced to acquire british citizenship. Wittgenstein, appalled by james frazers depiction of. Frazers influence also extends into the literary sphere, so one needs to have some familiarity when approaching work such as the wasteland. In 1929 wittgenstein returned to cambridge to work out a new philosophy. Ludwig wittgenstein remarks on frazers golden bough. Remarks on frazers golden bough 1979 edition open library. Alexander george reason and religion amherst college. His voluminous manuscripts were edited and published posthumously. The golden bough could almost could be said to comprise a modern mythology about mythology. The difference between them is that frazers work is now widely dismissed, even ridiculed.
The golden bough by frazer, first edition abebooks. Philosophical occasions, 19121951 edited by james c. In 1931 ludwig wittgenstein wrote his famous remarks on frazers golden bough. Remarks on frazers golden bough paperback by ludwig wittgenstein another useful book mercifully collected by rush rhys we owe him a lot for his. Wittgenstein began writing on frazer in his manuscript book on june 19. The blue book, socalled for the covers in which it circulated, was prepared by wittgenstein for his students, and hence offers a more straightforward exposition of the tenets contained within it than the investigations. Most readers are familiar with the one volume version of the golden bough as an abridgement of the third edition, made by frazer in 1922. Ever since its first edition in 1890, the golden bough has been considered a major influence in the development of western thought.
Bemerkungen uber frazers the golden bough is a collection of ludwig wittgensteins thoughts on james. Remarks on frazers golden bough is a collection of ludwig wittgensteins thoughts on james george frazers the golden bough. The golden bough, a study of comparative religion by sir james frazer. Remarks on frazers golden bough paperback by ludwig wittgenstein another useful book mercifully collected by rush rhys we owe him a lot for his recordings of snatches of wittgensteins thoughts. The golden bough 2 volume in one book by frazer james avenel, 1981 edition, isbn. Robert frasers masterful 1994 abridgement distils these riches, retaining frazers most controversial passages, honouring his original fourbook structure, and. Note sul ramo doro di frazer, milano, adelphi, 2000. Zu wittgensteins bemerkungen uber frazers the golden bough philipp brunner. Frazer, a cambridge researcher trained in classical literature, outlines ancient myths and folk legends, proposing that all civilizations go through three stages of development. Wittgenstein, modern music, and the myth of progress.
In recent years, analytic philosophy has gained a new historical selfcon sciousness. She has travelled more than 140,000 miles 225,000 km, a distance equal to more than five times around the globe. However, while previous editors make ref erenee only to wittgensteins own onevolume edition,6 we also incude in braekets the eorresponding volume and page numbers for the large stan dard edition othe golden bough. Most of them were included in a typescript wittgenstein worked on. Publication date 1900 topics mythology, religion, magic, superstition publisher london. View wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough research papers on academia.
Frazer regards them as nascent forms of contemporary science that reflect faulty views about physics, medicine, or technology wittgenstein 1993, p. Parts of the golden bough frazer 1922 were read to him in 1930 and his remarks 1979 on frazer were written down by hand in the summer of 1931. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Buy remarks on frazers golden bough by wittgenstein, ludwig isbn. The golden bough, james george frazer, apr 26, 2012, history, 410 pages. Buy the golden bough a study in magic and religion oxford worlds classics.
According to clack, the fate which befell wittgensteins views on religion, also befell the interpretation of wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough. James george frazer frazer, james george, 18541941 a wikipedia article about this author is available frazer, james george, 18541941, contrib bantu beliefs and magic, with particular reference to the kikuyu and kamba tribes of kenya colony. Ludwig wittgenstein, the blue and brown books philpapers. Frazer, wittgenstein and the interpretation of ritual practice felicia desmith frazer and wittgenstein, anthropologist and philosopher, are two thinkers whose works have profoundly shaped the development of their respective fields in the 20th century. Ludwig josef johann wittgenstein 26 april 1889 29 april 1951 was an austrianbritish philosopher who worked primarily in logic, the philosophy of mathematics, the philosophy of. To think that it is, he argues, is to take insufficient account of wittgensteins preoccupation with logic, and it is to gloss over the consideration that the sparse remarks about ethical value roughly from 6. Remarks on frazers anthropology, edited and translated by kenneth laine ketner and james leroy eigsti. Open library is an open, editable library catalog, building towards a web page for every book ever published. The golden hinde launched 1973 is a fullsize replica of the golden hind launched 1577. Introductory note to the remarks on frazers golden bough. Wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough page 1 of 2. Buy remarks on frazers golden bough first english language edition by wittgenstein, ludwig, miles, a. Wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough notes. On the ketner and eigsti edition of wittgensteins remarks.
However, there is another edition, called ludwig wittgenstein. Publishers note to wittgenstein on frazer it is now nearly forty years since the late rush rhees, having seen that wittgensteins remarks on frazer constitute a short book and having done the. Last but not least ist ludwig wittgenstein zu erwahnen. He is considered by many to be the most prominent philosopher of the xx century. A study in magic and religion, ist eine umfassende. Remarks on frazers golden bough by ludwig wittgenstein. Remarks on frazers golden bough, notes for lectures on. Setting a reading intention helps you organise your reading. Free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. Wittgenstein, the blue book j a perspicuous representation brings about the understanding which consists precisely in the fact that we see the connections. Wittgenstein wrote the text in the summer of 1931, which represented his earliest efforts to compose. Wittgenstein, remarks on frazers golden bough free download as pdf file. The twovolume edition that was familiar to hardy and yeats remains a sketch. From 1929 to 1947, wittgenstein taught at the university of cambridge.
Text is clean and unmarked, binding tight, tanning of pages due to age. The firefestivals of europe and the doctrine of the external soul, sir james george frazer, 19, magic. Lots of philosophy geeks end with wittgensteins tractatus and dismiss his break with his own work in remarks on colour and his blue and brown books. Disproving the popular thought that primitive life was simple, this monumental survey shows that savage man was enmeshed in a. The golden bough sir james frazer the golden bough describes our ancestors primitive methods of worship, sex practices, strange rituals and festivals. The full length third edition is frazers definitive statement in which the king of the wood appears in a radically new guise. Frazer, wittgenstein and the interpretation of ritual practice. This massive work surveys the spiritual beliefs, practices, and institutions. Philosophical investigations appeared as a book in 1953. Wittgenstein, remarks on frazers golden bough ludwig. Although many philosophers have noted parallels between wittgenstein and heidegger, the present paper argues that heideggers account of his fundamental concept, the ereignis, the opening of the open sheehan, 2001. The commentary was initially published in 1967, with an english edition in 1979. Together with some reflections on east africa after the war london.
It was originally published in two volumes in 1890 with the subtitle a study in comparative religion and was enlarged and republished with the subtitle a study in magic and religion 12 volumes, 191115. It features an article by christian erbacher entitled wittgenstein and his literary executors. She was built by traditional handcraft in appledore, north devon. The golden bough a study in magic and religion oxford worlds.
James george frazer frazer, james george, 18541941. Golden hinde 1973 project gutenberg selfpublishing. A study in magic and religon by sir james george frazer and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Ludwig wittgenstein was an austrianbritish philosopher who worked primarily in the fields of epistemology, logic, philosophy of mathematics, philosophy of mind and philosophy of language. Wittgensteins remarks on frazers golden bough research. Stout and the psychological origins of analytic philosophy by. Heideggers ereignis and wittgenstein on the genesis of.
581 170 1085 1298 1514 1034 1400 321 1463 827 1475 49 431 969 414 1402 1093 966 1060 1571 701 319 82 392 763 152 279 1206 26 561 88 1155 474 977 250 732 899 694 138 1090 1358 1443 1198